| Category | Parameter | Wt. | Score | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quality | Business Quality | 10.00% | 8.5 | 📌 Craytheon.com; Sahi.com, 2026 India's largest paint manufacturer with a 10-year revenue CAGR of 8.6% — genuine long-term category leadership, now showing a real recovery after 6 consecutive quarters of decline. |
| Quality | Management Quality | 10.00% | 7.5 | 📌 Sharekhan Q2 FY26 Note, Nov 2025 Guided realistically for mid-single-digit value growth and 18-20% OPM for FY26 rather than overpromising, and delivered a genuine double-digit volume beat. |
| Quality | Growth Visibility | 10.00% | 7 | 📌 Sahi.com Q4 FY26, May 2026 Q4 FY26 PAT surged 69% YoY on double-digit volume growth — a real recovery signal after a prolonged multi-quarter slump, though sustainability needs more quarters of proof. |
| Quality | Moat | 10.00% | 8 | 📌 Sharekhan Q2 FY26 Note, Nov 2025 Deep distribution network built over decades remains a genuine moat, though higher competitive intensity (from Grasim's Birla Opus entry) is a real, active threat. |
| Quality | Capital Allocation | 6.67% | 8 | 📌 Sahi.com Q4 FY26, May 2026 FY26 total dividend of ₹27.50/share reflects strong cash generation even through a challenging multi-year period — capital discipline maintained. |
| Quality | Balance Sheet | 6.67% | 8.5 | 📌 Craytheon.com, 2026 Excellent balance sheet health — interest coverage of 28x and debt-to-equity of just 0.18 indicate very low financial risk. |
| Quality | Risk Profile | 6.66% | 6.5 | 📌 Sharekhan Q2 FY26 Note, Nov 2025 Higher competitive intensity in the paints category (new large entrants) and an extended monsoon both remain live headwinds even amid the recent recovery. |
| Price | Valuation | 13.33% | 4.5 | 📌 Cholasecurities, 2026 PE around 55-60x is a significant premium even after the recent earnings recovery — the market is pricing sustained double-digit growth resuming. |
| Price | FCF Yield | 13.33% | 5.5 | 📌 Craytheon.com, 2026 Excellent 1-year operating cash flow (1.6x of earnings) supports genuine cash generation, though the rich valuation compresses the effective yield. |
| Price | Reverse DCF | 13.34% | 4.5 | 📌 Sharekhan Target ₹3,360, Nov 2025 Sharekhan's target of ₹3,360 assumes the recovery in volumes and margins is durable, not a one-off bounce — a meaningfully optimistic assumption given only 1-2 quarters of proof so far. |
| Quality 60.00% / Price 40.00% | 6.57 | |||
| Development | Status |
|---|---|
| Volume growth recovery sustains for 3+ consecutive quarters, confirming it's structural not a bounce | Monitor |
| Valuation corrects toward ~40-45x PE without a change in the improving fundamentals | Positive |
| Metric | Current | Historical | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| PE (Trailing) | ~55-60x | ~69x (FY25) | Cholasecurities, 2026 |
| ROE | 21.34% | 20.9% (FY25) | Cholasecurities, 2026 |
| ROCE | 26.68% | 17.1% (FY25) | Cholasecurities, 2026 |
| Promoter Holdings | ~42.68% | Stable | Cholasecurities, 2026 |
| Competitor | Segment | Threat |
|---|---|---|
| Birla Opus (Grasim) | Paints | High |
| Berger Paints / Kansai Nerolac | Paints | Medium |
| JSW Paints | Paints | Medium |