| Category | Parameter | Wt. | Score | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quality | Business Quality | 10.00% | 7.5 | 📌 Kotak Neo Q4 FY26 Note, Apr 2026 World's largest coal mining company by production volume, holding a dominant position in India's still-substantial coal-dependent power generation mix. |
| Quality | Management Quality | 10.00% | 6.5 | 📌 CMA S9 Framework Analysis Consistent production and dividend delivery typical of a mature PSU coal producer, though growth strategy is inherently tied to India's energy policy direction. |
| Quality | Growth Visibility | 10.00% | 5.5 | 📌 CMA S9 Framework Analysis Coal demand growth is structurally moderating as India accelerates renewable energy adoption — Coal India's long-term growth visibility is genuinely capped by this transition. |
| Quality | Moat | 10.00% | 7.5 | 📌 CMA S9 Framework Analysis Near-monopoly position in domestic coal production with extensive mining rights is a genuine structural moat, though the moat protects a slowly maturing market. |
| Quality | Capital Allocation | 6.67% | 7.5 | 📌 Kotak Neo Q4 FY26 Note, Apr 2026 Declared a dividend of ₹5.25/share for Q4 alone — Coal India has a long history of generous dividend payouts typical of a mature, cash-generative PSU. |
| Quality | Balance Sheet | 6.67% | 7.5 | 📌 CMA S9 Framework Analysis As a mature, high-margin PSU with limited need for heavy reinvestment, Coal India typically maintains a strong, low-leverage balance sheet. |
| Quality | Risk Profile | 6.66% | 5.5 | 📌 CMA S9 Framework Analysis Long-term structural risk from India's energy transition away from coal is real, even if near-term coal demand (backed by NTPC's continued thermal capacity additions) remains resilient. |
| Price | Valuation | 13.33% | 7 | 📌 Company data, 2026 Coal India typically trades at a low PE reflecting both its high dividend yield and the market's awareness of long-term structural transition risk — appropriately conservative pricing. |
| Price | FCF Yield | 13.33% | 7.5 | 📌 Kotak Neo Q4 FY26 Note, Apr 2026 Strong dividend payout history combined with limited capex needs typically supports a high free cash flow yield for Coal India relative to capital-intensive peers. |
| Price | Reverse DCF | 13.34% | 6.5 | 📌 Analyst consensus, 2026 Current valuation appears to price in a gradual, not abrupt, decline in coal's role in India's energy mix — reasonable given NTPC's continued near-term thermal capacity build-out. |
| Quality 60.00% / Price 40.00% | 6.87 | |||
| Development | Status |
|---|---|
| Coal demand from thermal power generation remains resilient longer than currently expected, given NTPC's continued capacity additions | Monitor |
| Dividend yield remains attractive relative to alternative income-generating investments | Positive |
| Metric | Current | Historical | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| PAT Growth (Q4 FY26) | +12% YoY | — | Kotak Neo, Apr 2026 |
| Revenue Growth (Q4 FY26) | +6% YoY | — | Kotak Neo, Apr 2026 |
| Q4 FY26 Dividend | ₹5.25/share | — | Kotak Neo, Apr 2026 |
| Related: NTPC Coal PLF (context) | 72.04% | vs 63.20% India avg | Cross-reference: NTPC FY26 data |
| Competitor | Segment | Threat |
|---|---|---|
| NLC India | Coal Mining (PSU) | Low |
| Adani Enterprises (coal mining/trading) | Coal Mining/Trading | Low |
| Renewable energy providers (structural, not direct) | Power Generation | Medium |